Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 2 of 2 1 2
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 8,152
Likes: 1
A
Member
Offline
Member
A
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 8,152
Likes: 1
Roo, it's your XW's legal time with D, correct? Then you should facilitate it. You are legally bound to anyway. Explain to D that you don't have a choice, legally you are obligated to make sure W has her time with D.

As for it being a no-win situation, you should be thick-skinned enough from your XW's behavior by now that you know it's not a reflection on you. If she starts to rant and rave then tell her "we are not married and I am under ZERO obligation to take your abuse and I WILL NOT tolerate it. Then end the convo.

Quote
If I ask D14 what she would like and respond to my XW with her answer, which will likely be no, then I will likely get an email accusing me of not following the parenting plan and preventing her from seeing D14.


And she would have a point. It's a legal agreement, it's not about whether D wants to go or not. If you have to make her go against her will then that's what you should do.

Quote
If I don't respond I usually get an email that says I am not being a good co-parent or communicating with her in regards to D14.


And she would be right.

Quote
If I have D14 take care of it since it is her time with her mom then I usually receive an email saying I put D14 in the middle of a parenting decision.


And she would be right again.

Quote
If I tell XW this would be a great question for D14 and you should ask her then I get an email telling me visitation is a legal agreement between the two of us and not D14.


Right again.

Do you see the one option that you DIDN'T list? The correct and legal one. You tell XW that D will be ready at the appointed time, then you tell D that her mother will be picking her up at X time on X day and that she needs to be ready. Period. "Oh but I don't want to blah blah blah!" Validate. "I am sorry, I know this is difficult for you." "So I don't have to go?" "You still have to go, it may be difficult but it is the right thing to do. She is still your mother and she wants to spend time with you."

Quote
D14 therapist has asked XW to leave me out of things like this because it causes an unhealthy communication triangle but I still get these emails that either ask me for permission to see her, ask me what the plans are, or something like it. I can't seem to escape being put in a no win situation.


I think she's wrong. But ask your lawyer if you're not sure.

Last edited by AnotherStander; 02/12/20 07:43 PM.

Me: 60 w/ S18, D24, D27

M: 21 years; BD: 06-14-12; S: 09-10-12; D final: 03-17-14; XW:57
Joined: Jul 2019
Posts: 473
D
DS9 Offline
Member
Offline
Member
D
Joined: Jul 2019
Posts: 473
Hey Roo

How are you buddy? I'm glad to hear you splurged and got a new bedroom suite.

Those emails really shed a light on the bizarre thinking patterns of these MLC people don't they.

If the fresh litigation the XW instigated is going ahead, and your D is continuing to resist going to her mum, then i think you need to take some urgent legal advice about the prospects of varying the agreement to take your D's wishes into account, and to tie up this seeming loose end where XW keeps contacting you.

Get advice too on what this children's lawyer's role is for your D, and ask your L to clearly tell you what are your responsibilities under the current agreement if D doesn't want to go.

I see you're struggling mate but I think this is a legal issue outside the scope of what we here in the forum can guide you with.

Keep us posted and good luck Roo

Cheers DS


Me: early 40's
XW: nearly 50
T: 15
M: 5
BD: Jan 19
S:10 SS: 22 SD: 24
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
R
Member
OP Offline
Member
R
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
I went with my usual reply and said D14 will be ready for pick up at he agreed upon time.

AS this was more of a rant than anything else. You said on almost all the replies that she would have a point and you are right. That was actually my point that if I answered her actual question which was "does D14 want to visit with me" then I was screwed no matter what I did. By doing what I usually do and what you suggested I don't really answer her question I just tell her what I am going to do. More than anything I am realizing this is what completely destroyed our marriage. If she asked me something no matter how I answered or not answered she took offense to it and became the victim. If I just took an action then she felt it abusive in some way. An example would be she wanted to know if she was allowed to buy uniforms for work. If I said yes then she said see I have to ask for approval, if I said no we are tight on budget this week then I was controlling, if I said you don't need my permission then I wasn't husband showing leadership, if I said anything about this question being unfair and putting me in role of a parent rather than a partner then she accused me of being angry. Always love your advice AS and working on becoming thicker skinned but I hate that she always asks questions that seem designed to trap me.

DS I am not worried legally about any of this. I have already talked to my lawyer and he is not concerned about anything. This was more of a rant than anything. We both have our lawyers and D14's lawyers role is to inform and protect her rights as a minor. She is also there to make sure D14's voice is heard in the courtroom. My lawyer informed me my responsibilities are to present D14 at the agreed upon time and encourage D14 to go to the visitation. Both my lawyer and D14 therapist said to never physically force her to go as that can be considered child abuse. The problem is not getting her to go when she doesn't want to, the problem is she never stays for the whole visit and then I am blamed for it. My lawyer said well XW has physical custody and if she brings her back early then you don't need to worry about it as long as you aren't the one picking her up or convincing her to come back early.

I just found out the reason she was asking. She doesn't want D14 over this weekend because she has a roommate moving in who she has never even met. The roommate supposedly passed a background check at her workplace, which means she has a job so that is a bonus. This is a huge blow to D14 since her mother just told her tonight that the roommate will be moved in this Friday. D14 is mad because she felt her mom could have told her she was looking for a roommate awhile ago and felt she deserved more than a day and a half notice. I don't mind because this seems to be a wise financial decision for XW and D14 isn't really over there long enough for it to affect her too much. I just wish XW was more transparent with things. Why would she want to hide something like this until the last second.


1st BD December 26, 2008
PA admitted to by XW December 29, 2008

2nd BD May 23, 2019
Daughter confirms EA
Divorce Finalized July 18, 2019
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
R
Member
OP Offline
Member
R
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
D14 is cautiously optimistic about the new roommate. She went to her room and played video games with her and they talked about the music they liked. XW apparently just stayed downstairs and didn't engage either of them. I think this may be a little help sent from heaven so D14 has a person to talk to when she is over for visitation. That is the good news.

The bad news is XW told D14 that she is going to be moving in with a friend in a couple months. This friend of XW's has a husband and two children. They have a four bedroom house and XW will be staying in the 4th bedroom and when D14 comes over for visitation D14 will sleep in the bedroom and her mom will sleep somewhere else in the house on a futon. D14 is not very happy about this situation because she doesn't want to go live at some strange families house.

D14 did get angry during visitation and talked to her mom about a lot of things but one of them that stood out was when she said "I can't believe you told dad you have been faking your love for him since your last affair 10 years ago." Hearing this D14 said she smirked at her and said "oh, I have been faking it a lot longer than that." Towards the end of their argument she told D14 "I know what is best for you and you are a spoiled little brat." Once again XW dropped off D14 early and once again I got an email blaming me for it.

I continue to work on myself in IC. Both D14's therapist and my own therapist are working on getting us to except XW for who she is. We don't need to agree with her actions, values, morals, beliefs, but accept that this is the person she is and we can't change that. We both need to let go of the idea of who we wanted her to be.

Today D14 is getting a Rotary Youth Leadership award for her leadership and hard work at school and in the community. She will have to give a speech and it will be at a fancy hotel with lots of guests so she is kind of nervous. I know she will do great. Her mom has chosen not to attend the event. It will be alright because I will be there to support her, show her how proud I am, and most importantly that she is loved.


1st BD December 26, 2008
PA admitted to by XW December 29, 2008

2nd BD May 23, 2019
Daughter confirms EA
Divorce Finalized July 18, 2019
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 8,152
Likes: 1
A
Member
Offline
Member
A
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 8,152
Likes: 1
Originally Posted by rooskers
By doing what I usually do and what you suggested I don't really answer her question I just tell her what I am going to do. More than anything I am realizing this is what completely destroyed our marriage. If she asked me something no matter how I answered or not answered she took offense to it and became the victim. If I just took an action then she felt it abusive in some way. An example would be she wanted to know if she was allowed to buy uniforms for work. If I said yes then she said see I have to ask for approval, if I said no we are tight on budget this week then I was controlling, if I said you don't need my permission then I wasn't husband showing leadership, if I said anything about this question being unfair and putting me in role of a parent rather than a partner then she accused me of being angry. Always love your advice AS and working on becoming thicker skinned but I hate that she always asks questions that seem designed to trap me.


I 100% get what you are saying, even though you know it's not about you it still hurts to be treated like she treats you. It is frankly emotional and mental abuse. You are handling things really well, I definitely respect your ability to keep cool and calm and collected in the face of her behavior.

Quote
the problem is she never stays for the whole visit and then I am blamed for it. My lawyer said well XW has physical custody and if she brings her back early then you don't need to worry about it as long as you aren't the one picking her up or convincing her to come back early.


That's exactly what I was going to say. If W brings her back early then so be it (assuming it doesn't mess with your schedule). If she wants to blame you for HER bringing D back early, well that's just laughable.

It sure sounds like she has some very real mental issues. I do some work in a mental hospital, as an architect but I am around the patients a lot and observe their behavior. The really scary ones are the ones that have a very normal outward middle upper class appearance and can engage you with very normal conversation. Then they hit you with the "crazy". It's so weird and unexpected that it could easily make you think you're the crazy one, that you are hearing wrong or interpreting wrong. It's one thing being in a mental hospital because you know who the patients are, but these people out in the real world could really cause some havoc. What you describe about your W reminds me of some of those patients. I'm sure she's not in IC either, but man she sure could use it.

Quote
D14 did get angry during visitation and talked to her mom about a lot of things but one of them that stood out was when she said "I can't believe you told dad you have been faking your love for him since your last affair 10 years ago." Hearing this D14 said she smirked at her and said "oh, I have been faking it a lot longer than that." Towards the end of their argument she told D14 "I know what is best for you and you are a spoiled little brat." Once again XW dropped off D14 early and once again I got an email blaming me for it.


That is borderline abusive behavior. I really feel for your D, I mean this is her mother and how sad to be treated that way by someone she wants to admire and respect and aspire to. It's terrible.

Quote
Both D14's therapist and my own therapist are working on getting us to except XW for who she is. We don't need to agree with her actions, values, morals, beliefs, but accept that this is the person she is and we can't change that. We both need to let go of the idea of who we wanted her to be.


She sounds like poison to me. My personal experience with toxic relatives is that they can't be changed and the best approach is to cut them out of your life. Do your and D's ICs tell you to accept her and welcome her, or are they saying to accept that she is a toxic person and move to cut her out of your lives?

Quote
Today D14 is getting a Rotary Youth Leadership award for her leadership and hard work at school and in the community. She will have to give a speech and it will be at a fancy hotel with lots of guests so she is kind of nervous. I know she will do great.


That's fantastic! Proud daddy moment for sure!

Quote
Her mom has chosen not to attend the event.


Wow you have absolutely got to be kidding me. Could she be any worse of a mother.


Me: 60 w/ S18, D24, D27

M: 21 years; BD: 06-14-12; S: 09-10-12; D final: 03-17-14; XW:57
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
R
Member
OP Offline
Member
R
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
Quote
I'm sure she's not in IC either, but man she sure could use it. Do your and D's ICs tell you to accept her and welcome her, or are they saying to accept that she is a toxic person and move to cut her out of your lives?


She tells D14 she is in therapy and working through the abuse she has been put through by everyone in her life. Parents, college friends, high school friends, boyfriends, girlfriends, ex-husband and everyone else connected to her past. IC can only help if you are being honest on what the problems are. I was told that her previous therapist will not work with her anymore after she lied to him repeatedly and put him in a position that put his license at risk.

My therapist is working on me accepting that XW has some deep issues that she needs to work on alone and with a professional. I need to accept that the divorce was the right decision given the circumstances and the most loving thing I can do for myself, my daughter and my XW is to cut XW out of my life as much as possible and give XW the space to work on healing if she so chooses. I am also continuing to be a pillar of strength and consistency in D14's life.

D14 has to accept the fact that she will have to have her mom in her life until she is 18 and then can make her own decisions on whether she would be better cutting all ties or not. Her IC is working on D14 accepting that her mom has issues that have nothing to do with her. She is working on D14 learning how to set up strong boundaries, being assertive but respectful in her communication and finally to learning to live with someone who may have a serious mental disorder. D14's mom requested the therapy notes from D14's counseling sessions which the therapist was legally obligated to provide her. I can't tell you what was in the notes but rest assured her mom has read them all and has been using D14's pain, fears, and hurt as a weapon against D14 during visitations. In response D14's therapist and lawyer have told D14 her rights in this state allow D14 to consent to her own mental health which will enable her to fill out her own paperwork as if she were an emancipated minor. D14 felt she needed this because her mom told her she was going to seek legal action to prevent D14 from seeing her current therapist and also so D14 can keep her therapy sessions private.


Last edited by rooskers; 02/19/20 07:14 PM.

1st BD December 26, 2008
PA admitted to by XW December 29, 2008

2nd BD May 23, 2019
Daughter confirms EA
Divorce Finalized July 18, 2019
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 8,152
Likes: 1
A
Member
Offline
Member
A
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 8,152
Likes: 1
Wow!!!! Well I'm glad you and D are getting some good help but frankly the more you say about XW the more scary she sounds. It sounds like the therapists don't see her as a danger to anyone? People who have mental health issues can have extremely violent outbursts with zero warning, that's how most of them end up institutionalized. I would be extremely concerned! Originally I said you should do what you can to facilitate visits between her and D, but now I'm not so sure. I mean legally you have to, but maybe you should petition to allow only supervised visitation.

Quote
I can't tell you what was in the notes but rest assured her mom has read them all and has been using D14's pain, fears, and hurt as a weapon against D14 during visitations.


That is really disturbing. Are you sure you can't go back to court with D and petition for emancipation? She sounds very mature, I would think the court would be inclined to back her up on this.


Me: 60 w/ S18, D24, D27

M: 21 years; BD: 06-14-12; S: 09-10-12; D final: 03-17-14; XW:57
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
R
Member
OP Offline
Member
R
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
Yesterday was 10 months to the day she said "I don't love you, your a negative person, I don't want to be married, I have been faking it for years, take care of D14" and left. Since that time she has never brought up our relationship or has even asked to talk about it. She called up my mom and my best friend for 35 years the morning after BD and told them I am leaving him, it isn't because of a guy, and I want a clean slate. It still shocks me that after 22 years she just up and left one day. The only communication between us has been emails about D14. It still seems so weird that the week before she left she was talking about our future and the Hawaii trip we had planned and then the next thing I new she left.


1st BD December 26, 2008
PA admitted to by XW December 29, 2008

2nd BD May 23, 2019
Daughter confirms EA
Divorce Finalized July 18, 2019
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
R
Member
OP Offline
Member
R
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 239
I would like some opinions on this one. I have said before that XW has decided she would like to move in with a friend on May 1. This friend has been divorced and recently just got married to another guy. She has children one of which is a teenage boy who is similar in age as D14. The friend, new husband, children all live in a 4 bedroom house and wife plans on taking one of the rooms. This is not a living situation like a separate living space downstairs or in a completely separate part of the house. The friend is also a counselor that has been coaching XW for a year on how to leave me, on the language to use for abuse, extreme distancing, and things like that. D14 told her mom last August that she had no wish to see or hang out with this person at all. This will force D14 to not only see her but live in her house with her her family and under her rules.

Questions/Concerns so you know where I am coming from ~

1) If D14 and the son fight who is in charge of the discipline? Friend, Husband, or XW
2) If son does something inappropriate who can D14 turn to in this case? Her mom has absolute trust in her friend.
3) If D14 wants to get something to eat who does she ask since it isn't her mom's house but her friends?
4) Will the friend and her husband have the right to discipline her since it is their house.
5) D14 will have absolutely no private space since she will be sharing a room with her mom and the other part of the house is her friends family space.

I have so many other concerns but I am trying to see if this is due to anger at my XW or if these are legitimate concerns. I truly feel that this is not personal but truly what is in the best interest of D14. Having her own place with a roommate seems reasonable, if she gets married while I wouldn't like it that would be my own issue to work through, but moving in with a newly married couple with children from a previous marriage and one being a teenage son? Please let me know what you think.

Last edited by rooskers; 02/26/20 10:04 PM.

1st BD December 26, 2008
PA admitted to by XW December 29, 2008

2nd BD May 23, 2019
Daughter confirms EA
Divorce Finalized July 18, 2019
Joined: Jul 2019
Posts: 473
D
DS9 Offline
Member
Offline
Member
D
Joined: Jul 2019
Posts: 473
Hey Roo,

I think the very first enquiry you might want to make is with your L to see if these changes to XW's living circumstances justify revisiting the agreement, or making visits subject to them not taking place at the new house, given your concerns. You might need hard evidence to justify your concerns, but I'd definitely relay all this to your L and get proper advice.

As to your queries, I think these touch on legal rights and responsibilities, so please talk to your L about this and get the right advice the first time so you can plan your actions or mitigating steps properly on a solid base.

I'm sorry if that 10 month anniversary was tough for you mate. You know though all that BS she spouted is just a history rewrite in justification for leaving. I think the more extreme the allegations and stories in the rewrite, the more we can be sure the LBS was a great person - kind of an exponentially inverse paradox or something! Mate, your XW's rewrite was pretty extreme so the only inference we can draw is you were one helluva AMOAFWL!

Keep that chin up DB brother! You're doing so well mate!

Cheers DS


Me: early 40's
XW: nearly 50
T: 15
M: 5
BD: Jan 19
S:10 SS: 22 SD: 24
Page 2 of 2 1 2

Moderated by  Cadet, DnJ, job, Michele Weiner-Davis 

Link Copied to Clipboard